Two European patients are confirmed to have been reinfected with the coronavirus, according to regional public broadcasters, raising concerns about people’s immunity to the virus as the world struggles to tame the pandemic.
The news follows a report by researchers in Hong Kong released on Monday about a man there who had been reinfected four-and-a-half months after recovering from his first infection, suggesting that some patients who recover from COVID-19 may have only short-lived immunity to reinfection.
Broadcasters said on Tuesday a patient in the Netherlands and another in Belgium had also been reinfected with the virus that has led to hundreds of thousands of deaths worldwide and crippled the global economy.
Dutch broadcaster NOS cited virologist Marion Koopmans as saying the patient in the Netherlands was an older person with a weakened immune system.
Let our news meet your inbox. The news and stories that matters, delivered weekday mornings.Sign Up
She said that cases where people have been sick with the virus a long time and it then flares up are better known.
But a true reinfection, as in the Dutch, Belgian and Hong Kong cases, requires genetic testing of the virus in both the first and second infection to see whether the two instances of the virus differ slightly.
Download the NBC News app for breaking news and politics
Koopmans, an adviser to the Dutch government, said reinfections had been expected.
“That someone would pop up with a reinfection, it doesn’t make me nervous,” she said. “We have to see whether it happens often.”
Belgian virologist Marc Van Ranst told Belgian broadcaster VRT he had not been surprised by the Hong Kong reinfection.
“For us it was not news because we have also had such a case in Belgium,” he told the Terzake programme.
The Belgian case was a woman who had contracted COVID-19 for a first time in the second week of March and for a second time in June.
“I think that in the coming days that we will see other similar stories … These could be exceptions, but do exist and it’s not just one,” Van Ranst said. “It’s not good news.”
Van Ranst said that in cases such as the Belgian woman’s in which the COVID-19 symptoms were relatively mild, the body may not have created enough antibodies to prevent a rinfection, although they might have helped limit the sickness.
The findings are likely to be significant for scientists who have been working on treatments using antibodies from recovered coronavirus patients, and those who have been scrambling to develop a safe and effective vaccine, though it’s too soon to draw any firm conclusions.