Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg likening farebeating to toll evasion is ludicrous — and sends a dangerous message


Besides assuring New York’s prison class it’s protected from prosecution for theft, assault, trespass and resisting arrest, new Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg promised subway farebeaters that his workplace gained’t press expenses in opposition to them.

As he explains in his now-infamous “Day One” memo, “Data, and my personal experiences, show that reserving incarceration for matters involving significant harm will make us safer.” We’d like to see these information. As for his “personal experiences” — how about he saves these for his memoir?

Bragg’s farebeating coverage isn’t a main change; his predecessor, Cy Vance, stopped prosecuting “theft of services” from the Metropolitan Transportation Authority in 2018. But stamping the DA’s seal of approval on fare evasion actually isn’t going to enhance the environment on subways which are filthy, scary and usually resemble a locked hospital ward on wheels. 

Enchanted by his program of reform and need to prolong the advantage of the doubt to each miscreant within the borough, Bragg doesn’t care in regards to the common straphanger. In truth, his lack of comprehension of the best way the subway works is so profound that you’d be excused for pondering he’s by no means ridden it.

Host John Berman requested Bragg a easy query on CNN’s “New Day”: “If you’re not going to prosecute fare evasion, why should I pay a subway fare?” Bragg responded, “If you’ve got an E-ZPass, and you go through the toll, they don’t stop you and arrest you there.” Instead, “they send you a ticket. That’s what we need to do on fare evasion.”

Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg
Bragg’s strategy to farebeating gained’t enhance the environment on subways which are already filthy and scary.

“The thesis is clear: The status quo’s not working,” Bragg added. 

This non sequitur is hardly logical, a lot much less a “thesis.” But different acolytes of chaos additionally love this tortured analogy. Public Advocate Jumaane Williams has fought a lengthy battle in opposition to subway police patrols from his safe house on Fort Hamilton Army garrison and additionally likened turnstile leaping to driving throughout a tolled bridge with out a transponder. “When was the last time someone asked for police to arrest drivers who don’t pay tolls?” Williams asked in October 2019, when the MTA started watching dwell feeds to spot fare evaders.

Williams repeated the purpose a few weeks later, calling the addition of 500 officers to the subways “outrageous and unacceptable” and declaring that “the state response [is] criminalizing Blk/Bwn New Yorkers in a way we’ve never done with Bridge/Tunnel fare evasion.” 

One apparent motive (although not apparent to Bragg or Williams, evidently): Port Authority police don’t chase each toll evader on the George Washington Bridge as a result of the system reads license-plate numbers and sends individuals payments. “Tolls by Mail” is an official approach of paying. Failure to pay your toll, furthermore, will lead to a violation, and three violations set off a vehicle-registration suspension. Driving a automotive with a suspended registration can lead to a 30-day jail sentence for a first offense — for New Yorkers of all colours.

But the technicalities of toll vs. fare evasion are inappropriate, and Bragg is aware of it. The subways are mass transit, that means that lots of persons are contained collectively in a single conveyance with no technique of escape. There is a lengthy historical past, evident once more, of delinquent people utilizing the subway system to discover victims, and criminals underground don’t often pay their fare. While it’s true that almost all farebeaters don’t beat or rob individuals, violent criminals virtually at all times leap the turnstile. 

A farebeater jumps the turnstile on the downtown 6 train platform at the MTA New York City Transit 86th Street subway station
A farebeater jumps the turnstile on the downtown 6 prepare platform on the 86th Street subway station.
Taidgh Barron/NY Post

It’s terrifying to be on a closed subway automotive when a hostile, vicious or mentally sick individual begins performing out. Such incidents are on the rise underground, as are murders and assaults. If toll evasion within the Holland Tunnel corresponded to a rise in street rage or carjacking, it might make sense to beef up safety and pull over evaders earlier than they acquired away.

Similarly, it is unnecessary to promote turnstile leaping by signaling to everybody that it’s OK. This is the true impact of Bragg’s hands-off insurance policies: Fare evasion, the MTA says, is at an all-time excessive. 

I do know nobody who believes that easy fare evasion deserves jail time, and the truth is virtually nobody went to Rikers for fare evasion even earlier than the daybreak of our new permissive utopia. But Bragg is sending a horrible message to New York City’s criminals, and they seem to be listening. 

Seth Barron is managing editor of The American Mind and creator of “The Last Days of New York.”

Comments are closed.